Thursday, October 27, 2016

Little snippets from Jacques Vallee's latest book - which I'd like to know more about

Hi all,

This post continues my look at aspects of Jacques Vallee's latest book, 'Forbidden Science - Volume Three.' Here, I draw the reader's attention to some items which I'd really like to know more about. If any reader is able to add to any of the snippets, this would be gratefully appreciated.

Russian ship crew sees 'flying cigar.'

'Later Kit told me he had seen an NSA intercept: A Russian ship off Gibraltar had sent a report to the oceanographic institute in Moscow. The crew had observed a flying cigar with a searchlight, in full daylight. It split into two objects that manoeuvred overhead. One object flew away, the other went on rolling and circling, and then melted on the spot.' (Vallee. p. 54. 20 November 1980.)


1. For a June 1984 UAP observation, near the Straits of Gibraltar, by a Russian ship crew member, click here.

2. 'Kit' is Dr Christopher 'Kit' Green

Remote viewing of Australian mountain

'Lunch with Hal...One of SRI's clients, an intelligence agency, has slipped the coordinates of Pat Price's four mountains among a test list for remote viewers. One site in Australia is well known locally for peculiar lights. The remote viewers correctly identified all four places as mountains and described underground installations.' (Vallee. p.103. 29 September 1982.)


1. Hal is Hal Puthoff. 

2. For more on SRI click here. 

Nuclear security testing

'I am reminded that Kit once interviewed a soldier of fortune, specialised in nuclear security testing, whose group used helicopters designed to appear as flying saucers.' (Vallee. p.137. 11 March 1984.)

European Space Agency UAP Project

(Speaking with Simonne Servais.) 'She reminded me that an attempt had been made to setup a research project within the European Space Agency, an organisation for which Louange long served in Madrid. The idea got nowhere.'


1. I can find no further references in Vallee to this, and an Internet search found nothing. However, I did find the following. 'Between 1991 and 1993, the idea of creating a Euro Centre to coordinate investigations into such reports was brought before the European Parliament ten times.' ('UFOs and Government: A Historical Inquiry. p.457.)

Other people tried to establish a team under SGDN, the General Secretariat for National Defense. Hubert Curien, minister of Industry, wrote to Hernu (at Defense) but the message went astray, going up the line of command instead of direct cabinet-level, and the project was aborted along the way.' (Vallee. p.19. 23 June 1985.)

Russian espionage and GEPAN

(Talking with Jean-Jacques Velasco.) 'We also spoke about Gepan. He told me that contacts with the Soviets had come to a halt when their Russian colleagues were thrown out of France for espionage, notably a scientist who had befriended Francois Louange. It turned out they were not interested in UFOs at all, but in some novel optical technology cnes was using.' (Vallee. p.326.28 April 1986.)


1. For the history of GEPAN click here.

2. Click here for more on cnes.

The Wild Weasels and UAP

'Jim McCampbell has made an interesting contact with some military pilots from the Wild Weasels. According to Jim, these are expert pilots who use F-4 planes equipped for electromagnetic detection, designed to identify ground radar, and first deployed during the Vietnam war. The story goes that they have detected many UFOs and have continued this role in the United States.' (Vallee. p.248. 22 June 1986.)

Silicon Valley study group 

'Yesterday Janine and I attended a meeting of an exclusive UFO study group assembled in Silicon Valley by Steve Millard. It was an opportunity to present a series of well-researched cases and get their advice.'

'The group includes John Hanes, former undersecretary of state under John Foster Dulles; Charlie Rosen, the founder of Machine Intelligence and a luminary of American robotic science; Attorney Bruce Garrett; and a group of high-tech engineers and entrepreneurs.

Charlie Rosen gave an enlightened critique of my work. He forcefully encouraged me to continue this research. He also made the interesting observation that the humanoid form of the ufonauts was the strongest argument against their extraterrestrial origin; not only would the biology of another planet be unlikely to produce beings adapted to our atmosphere and gravity, but an advanced civilisation would have used genetic manipulation to engage in space travel. (Vallee. p.267. 10 November 1986.)

'Our Silicon Valley UFO group met again on Monday. This time the audience included general 'Johnny' Johnson, former head of communications for the White House, and rear Admiral Bill Houser, former deputy chief of naval operations. The group wants to do something concrete, so Houser will ask the Navy to analyze the photographs I brought back from Costa Rico.'

'Admiral Bill Houser has given us the results of an analysis of the Costa Rico photograph by Naval Intelligence. They took a very cursory look, under the pretext that government resources shouldn't be wasted on such things, and declared that it must be a hoax because the shadows are on the wrong side of the disk. But the shadows are only on the wrong side if one makes the assumption the object is a solid cone. There is no justification for such an assumption.' (Vallee. p.267. 18 November 1986.)

French military intelligence in control

(In conversation with Boedec.) 'Who has given up his attempts to stimulate a new UFO research project in France: "I do have some friends in politics, especially in Britanny. But as soon as they reach a high level they clam up on this subject." We reached the conclusion that military intelligence was in control of the issue in France and would never allow an independent effort.' (Vallee. p.325. 18 June 1988.)


1. Boedec was a French researcher.

Saturday, October 22, 2016

The work of Richard Charles Niemtzow, 1975-1991


Recently, while reading Jacque Vallee’s latest book, ‘Forbidden Science – Volume Three,’ (2016. Documatica Research, LLC) I became interested in the research conducted by Richard Charles Niemtzow; an American researcher. I therefore undertook a literature search for material about him, and ended up compiling this post.


Richard Charles Niemtzow was born on 18 April 1942 at Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA. He attended the Admiral Farrgut Academy, High School, June 1960, in Pine Beach, New Jersey; then Emory University, Pre-Med Physics Major, 1960-1964, Atlanta, Georgia.

Between 1964-1965 he gained a BA at Goddard College, Plainfield, Vermont. He then undertook training to become a Medical Doctor, between 1965-1976 at Universite de Montpellier Faculte de Medecine, Montpellier, France.

He then gained a PhD in Biological Sciences, from Pacific Western University, Los Angeles, in February 1985. May 1992 saw him gain a Master’s degree in Public Health. He then attended the United States Air Force School of Aerospace Medicine, and became a Flight Surgeon, class of 891003, Brooks Air Force Base, Texas. [1]

The APRO Bulletin. Vol. 23 No. 5 March 1975. pp1&6

Article. Niemtzow, R. ‘Paralysis and UFO Close Encounters.’

The author (APRO representative for France and a medical student) presents a clinical sketch based on reports. ‘The problem of paralysis and the UFO close encounter can not be explained by current medical knowledge.’

MUFON Journal. No. 127. June 1978. pp6-7

Article. Niemtzow, R. C. & Schuessler, J. F. ‘Seeking the Mechanism for Paralysis in Close Encounter Cases.’

The two authors, members of the Houston, Texas, USA based Vehicle Internal Systems Investigative Team (VISIT) explore the issue of ‘…the paralysis of witnesses in close encounter cases.’

‘It appears that E-M fields may indeed be responsible for what ufologists have thought to be ‘radiation sickness;’ emphasizing the fact that E-M and not atomic radiation is associated with the UFO phenomena.’

‘Because of the selective paralysis of some bodily functions and the pathological absence involving the autonomic nervous system, Niemtzow has suggested elsewhere (APRO March 1975) that the clinical manifestations and paralytic pathways avoid the vital functions of the organism and that nerve trunk diameter seems the differentiating consideration of the paralytic process. This process seems to involve the large diameter nerves and in muscle innervation rather than the smaller fibres associated with autonomic regulation essential to the maintenance of life.’

MUFON Journal. No 131.Oct 1978. p19

‘Director’s Message.’ ‘Frequently in the Director’s message I discuss MUFON activities, which could be titled ‘News Around the Network.’ The Houston UFO group, identified as VISIT…holds monthly meetings…April 1, 1979 at the residence of Richard C Niemtzow, 1611 Ramada, Houston TX…’

MUFON Journal. No. 138. Aug 1979. p15

Article. Niemtzow, R. C. & Schuessler, J. F. ‘Humanoid Physiology.’

‘Collecting data relating human paralysis with the UFO phenomenon, the authors have discovered that the process seems to involve large diameter nerves associated with voluntary movement as opposed to the impunity of small diameter nerves found in regulatory functions delegated to the autonomous nervous system.’

MUFON Journal. No. 139. Sep 1979. pp3-4

Article. Niemtzow, R. C. & Schuessler, J. F. ‘CEIII in Tyler, Texas: Nightmares or reality?’

The authors report on two cases from Texas, in which the witnesses apparently know each other:
1. 17 Jan 1979. ‘Ron.’ Beam of light on hand and arm. Later weight loss; hair loss; burning eyes; diarrhea; excessive perspiration. Bleeding gums.

2. 24 Jan 1979. ‘Scott.’ Light hit him. Two ships seen. Scared; shaky; cold; stomach in knots. 5 inch across, diamond-shaped ‘burn’ on chest. Burnt hair. Burn on chest peeled in large, heavy slabs initially, but did not fade away.

‘One cannot rule out fabrication in this type of case, however it is the conclusion of this report that the participants have revealed the details truthfully and to the best of their ability.’

MUFON Journal. No 142. Dec 1979. p20

‘Lucius Farish.’ ‘In Others’ words.’

The 30 October 1979 issue of National Enquirer newspaper, has a feature which ‘…tells of Dr Richard Niemtzow’s research into the “paralysis effect” often noted in the vicinity of a UFO.’

MUFON Journal. No. 147. May 1980. p5

Article.  Niemtzow, R. C. & Schuessler, J. F. ‘Evaluation of Medical Injuries Resulting from UFO Close Encounters.’

The authors describe three categories of injuries. ‘The purpose of this paper is to recommend to physicians the acquisition of certain data that may be helpful in the clinical setting to evaluate and possibly assess the credibility of an actual close encounter.’

MUFON Journal. No. 147. May 1980. p7

‘Symposium Program.’ 11th annual MUFON Symposium on 7/8 Jun 1980, will include a talk by:
Niemtzow, R C ‘Preliminary Analysis of Medical Injuries as a Result of UFO Close Encounters.

MUFON Journal. No 149. Jul 1980. p3

‘Eleventh annual MUFON Symposium.’ This symposium was hosted by Project VISIT. ‘The abovementioned Project VISIT officers, as well as members Dr Richard C Niemtzow…are to be congratulated for lending their reputation, time and attention…’

MUFON Journal. No 149. Jul 1980. p12

Article. Niemtzow, Richard C. ‘Preliminary Analysis of Medical Injuries A Result of UFO Close Encounters.’

This paper, presented at the 1980 MUFON Symposium, explores categories of injuries, nerves involved, and psychological effects. ‘Unfortunately Niemtzow noted most CEIII witnesses have not been submitted to a complete physical examination immediately following their experience.’

MUFON Journal. No 154. Dec 1980. p14

Article. Stringfield, L H. ‘Status Report on Alleged Alien Cadaver Photos.’

‘As the day wore on, and as prearranged, I showed the photos selectively to a few more close researchers, medical personnel, NASA personnel…and Dr Richard Niemtzow….’

Vallee diary entry dated 22 February 1981

‘Kit came to see us last night…We spoke about Richard Niemtzow, an M.D. who is a friend of both Kit and Poher. Niemtzow, who is also close to John Schuessler, serves in the Air Force at Travis AFB near Sacramento. Gepan regularly calls him about close encounter cases in France. He advises them about appropriate tests, proposing to fly over to study the cases, but Gepan calls back every time to tell him it was a hoax after all.

“So why don’t they find a doctor in France?” asks Kit. “And isn’t it strange that it always turns out to be a hoax?”

1.       'Kit’ is Dr Christopher ‘Kit’ Green.

2.   Poher is Claude Poher. Poher’s background was in astronomy, astrophysics, space research and aeronautics. He created (in 1977) the official French UAP research group named Groupe d’Etudes Des Phenomenes Aerospatiaux Non-Identifes. Poher was GEPAN director between 1977 and 1979. [2]

3.       John Schuessler was an American researcher; MUFON member; member of VISIT based in Houston Texas. He worked, among other places, for McDonnell Douglas; Boeing, and NASA. [3]

Vallee diary entry dated 9 March 1981

‘Last night Janine and I had dinner with Richard Niemtzow and his wife Jacqueline at a Chinese restaurant at the Cannery. A major difference between us is that he searches for extra-terrestrial life with passionate idealism and relies on ufology as a path to discover it. His image of extra-terrestrial life is of beings similar to us, another big trap in my opinion. Along with John Scheussler, he is sure there is a Big Secret hidden by the government. Another trap? I suspect the truth is more mysterious, less simple and for the less romantic.

Niemtzow once met Rene Hardy, who told him: “If you want to solve the UFO problem, take a region 100 km in diameter…the phenomena is everywhere. Statistically you should be able to observe it yourself. “

I found Niemtzow smart but curiously impatient, looking around nervously, his eyes darting right and left as if he expected to detect spies, or sudden danger.’

MUFON Journal No 158. Apr 1981. p18

‘Director’s Message.’ ‘Richard C Nietzow, presently a Consultant in Radiation, has also accepted the post of State Section Director for Solano County…’

Vallee diary entry dated 27 April 1981

‘Richard Niemtzow is actively corresponding with Alain Esterle, the current head of Gepan. Richard believes that Kit doesn’t have access to what the US military is really doing. After his latest trip to France, Richard told Kit about Gepan’s interest in cooperating with the U.S. Kit wrote an official memo that reached the level of the president’s science adviser, but nothing happened. Richard also told me he had seen a copy of Frank Fontaine’s medical file.

1.       Alain Esterle was director of GEPAN between 1979 and 1983, during which GEPAN issued a series of technical notes. [4]

Vallee diary entry dated 6 May 1981

‘I have spoken to Esterle, first to relay a request by Niemtzow to become an official consultant (he does have this position on an individual basis, but not in his role with the Air Force) and to discuss Messengers.

MUFON Journal No. 165. Nov 1981. p6

‘Medical network.’

‘Project UFOMD – a network of doctors to intensively study UFO related injury cases – has been organised by radiologist Richard C Niemtzow. Before being called to active duty in the Air Force, Dr Niemtzow was active in MUFON and Project VISIT in the Houston, Texas area.

Doctors in the MUFO network are invited to contact Dr Niemtzow and offer their services.

Over about a 2-year period he hopes to investigate and assess a minimum of 12 cases dealing with medical injuries incurred during UFO close encounters, and possibly produce a catalogue correlating the resulting data. Investigators aware of such cases are urged to have the witness consult a physician of their choice, and Dr Niemtzow will be available as a consultant to the primary physician. Clinical and laboratory tests should be conducted on the witness in each case.

Interested physicians, including doctors working with patients reporting UFO-related injuries, should contact Dr Niemtzow at (707) 446-5050 or write to him at 532 Merchant Street, Varaville, CA 95688.

MUFON Journal No 161. Dec 1981. p18

‘On October 1, 1981, Richard C Niemtzow, MD, a consultant to MUFON, established a new project titled ‘National Investigation of Medical in juries Associated with Alleged UFO Close Encounters’ or simply UFOMD. For further information on this ambitious new project Please contact Dr Nietmzow at…MUFON endorses this new project and encourages our medical people to participate…’

MUFON Journal No. 167. Jan 1982. p19

Lucius Farish ‘In Other Words.’

‘In the December 1981 issue of the Journal under ‘Director’s Message,’ the formation of a new committee to study medical injuries associated with alleged UFO close encounters was announced by Richard C Niemtzow, M.D. Interested medical doctors and psychologists may contact Dr Niemtzow at 166 Cannon Drive, Travis AFB, CA 94535. (This is a revision from the original address supplied.)

MUFON Journal No 176. Oct 1982. p3

Article.  ‘Schuessler, J F. ‘Pentagon investigates Cash-Landrum.’

‘Approximately, two weeks later, I learned from Richard Niemtzow at Travis Air Force Base, that Capt Lampley had concluded her investigation and the results were negative.’ This was in reference to trying to find 23 helicopters said to have been involved in the Cash-Landrum case.

Schuessler, J.F. (1998.) ‘The Cash-Landrum UFO Incident.’ Geo graphics Printing co. La Porte, Texas. p145.

‘About two weeks later I heard from USAF Capt Richard Niemtzow, at Travis Air Force Base in California, that captain Lampley had concluded her investigation and the results were negative.” (Re the search for the helicopters.)

MUFON Journal No 179. Jan 1983. pp14-16

Article. Niemtzow, R C. ‘Radiation UFO Injuries.’

‘Alleged Medical Injuries from Intense Luminous Sources Stated To Be Unidentified Flying Objects. Project UFOMD Report No 1.’

Explores general issues such as a definition of the term radiation; paralysis; etc. “The exact mechanism of this paralysis remains poorly understood. ‘

On the Cash-Landrum case – ‘I will only speculate what occurred in the Cash-Landrum case because I never examined or had access to their medical records.’

‘In May 1982, the author was solicited as a consultant to the U.S. Army Inspector General’s Office, Washington DC dealing with the Cash-Landrum case…The medical data used by the author was solely that reported by various UFO journals. Clearly there is the need for better medical data gathering and reporting which has now become our responsibility by way of default.’

MUFON Journal No. 182 April 1983. p20

‘Director’s Message.’ The third edition of the MUFON Field Investigator’s Manual includes ‘Richard Niemtzow, M.D. and John F Schuessler for section XV, titled ‘Evaluation of Medical Injuries from UFO Close Encounters.’

MUFON Journal No. 187. Sep 1983. p18

‘Director’s message.’ ‘Richard C Niemtzow, M.D. (Capt. USAF) has been transferred from Travis, AFB in California to Andrews AFB in Maryland. He has advised that correspondence concerning ‘Project UFOMD’ should now be addressed to him at 1111 Boston Road, Andrews AFB, Maryland 20335 USA. His new telephone number is (301) 599-8957.’

Flying Saucer Review (UK). 1984. Vol. 29 No 3

Discusses the Cash-Landrum case; radiations; microwaves; and physiological effects.

MUFON Journal No. 193. March 1984.  p19

‘Director’s message.’ ‘Bruce S Maccabee, State Director for Maryland has approved the appointment of two new state section directors. Richard C Niemtzow, M.D., a consultant in Radiation and former state section director in California, has been transferred to Andrew AFB and is responsible for Prince Georges County. Dr Niemtzow is a captain in the USAF.’

Vallee diary entry dated 29 April 1985

‘Allen called with two pieces of news: one, we have been invited to go to France along with Richard Niemtzow to visit Gepan, following similar contacts the French plan to have with the Russians to discuss UFO research.’

Vallee diary entry dated 6 May 1985

‘Speaking to Richard Niemtzow I’ve learned something new about Gepan. The changes relayed by Allen’s call to me have their origin in a decision by Prime Minister Laurent Fabius who gave orders to increase Gepan’s budget. Velasco is now looking for better international contacts, including the USSR.’

1.       Velasco refers to Jean-Jacques Velasco, head of GEPAN/SEPRA between 1983 and 2004.[5]

Vallee diary entry dated 19 May 1985

‘Richard Niemtzow finally called: we do have a formal invitation from Gepan for Allen and me to travel to Toulouse and also to meet with members of the science board in Paris. This is Gepan’s last hope: the managers need to hear face-to-face confirmation that real American scientist like us are interested in the phenomena. So I’ll be there in late June…Richard made it clear that the higher levels of CNES were thinking of disbanding Gepan. If our trip fails to convince them that the subject has real scientific potential, they will probably stop all funding.’

1.       CNES refers to The Centre national d’etudes spatiales.

Vallee diary entry dated 9 June 1985

‘Back in San Francisco my daughter picked me up at the airport. She said Niemtzow had called, anxious to plan our French trip.’

Vallee diary entry dated 23 June 1985

‘Jean-Jacques Velasco, current head of Gepan, was supposed to meet us at Hotel Violet at 9.30am but he was two hours late, having boarded the wrong flight at Toulouse. This gave me time to talk at length with Niemtzow and Allen. Dr Richard Niemtzow, a close friend of John Scheussler and Kit who has a long term interest in physiological effects of UFOs, is an intense looking man with a high bald forehead, mid-forties, eyes alive, a curious mind. A major in the Air Force, he heads up a trial project for cancer treatment. He hopes to get invited by the French military to study UFOs in France.

“Do you think I should ask Velasco to help me?” he asked.

‘He doesn’t have that kind of access,” I said “You’d be better with Mr Gruau. I understand he is the interface with the puppetmasters.”

The three of us next went over what we know of the Cash-Landrum case. Niemtzow and his friends have managed to track down the helicopters involved. They belong to the Army, but it declines responsibility because the machines had been borrowed by “another agency” to carry out that project. Niemtzow thinks NSA is the party involved but a general has pointed out to him that “if they liked their jobs they should both keep quiet about it…”

…Niemtzow is certain that the extra-terrestrial evidence goes very far. His ambition is to be the first physician to uncover the existence of Aliens, and he dreams of the day when the first alien autopsy report can appear in a medical journal. He is in touch with Leonard Stringfield who promised to introduce him to a doctor who had done such an autopsy, so he mentioned the conversation to kit, who got angry at what he saw as his naïve acceptance of the claims. “Tell Stringfield to drop the whole thing!” Kit told Richard. When Stringfield lost his job shortly afterwards, Richard’s curiosity was further excited.’

Mr Gruau refers to Mr Gruau, Inspector General of the space centre and secretary to the GEPAN scientific council. [6]

Vallee diary entry dated 23 June 1985

‘After lunch Allen, Niemtzow and I met with Velasco again. He introduced us to Dr Brehamet and François Louange, both members of the Gepan team. We went over to Louange’s place, a fine apartment on the top floor of a house in the Marais, “older than the United States of America,’ he said. We reviewed the cast of characters at Cnes and their personal ambitions.’

‘…I have given a new research proposal to Allen, Velasco, Niemtzow and Poher. It concerns the implementation of an expert system for rapid computer screening of UFO reports. I deliberately picked information processing as my topic in forthcoming presentations to raise the technical level of the debate and keep it non-controversial.’

1.       Francois Louange was born in Versailles in 1945, qualified as a doctor-engineer in signal processing; joined the European Space Agency; became an independent consultant for French Defense. Since 2007 he has been an independent consultant to CNES/GEIPAN.[7]

Vallee diary entry dated 24 June 1985

‘Later at Hotel Violet with Niemtzow, Allen, and Kaye, conversation turned to the status of the new Center in Arizona.’

‘…Fortunately Richard Niemtzow saved the day with an impeccable presentation on medical effects. He mentioned Cash-Landrum, Bentwaters and six cases in Texas, including the diamond-shaped skin discolouration noted in Tyler on 24 January 1979.’

1.    Kaye refers to Jeffrey Kaye, a wealthy Englishman who assisted J Allen Hynek to move from Chicago to Scottsdale. [8]

Vallee diary entry dated 6 July 1985

‘I have drawn two conclusions from the Toulouse meeting: first Richard Niemtzow has convinced me that there was a secret project within the US government. In the Cash-Landrum case there were 23 helicopters around a flying object that melted the asphalt in the road and injured three people. These helicopters had been borrowed from an Army base by a group with extensive powers. The road was repaired the next day, the medium strip repaired with all traces erased…’

MUFON Journal No. 208. Aug 1985. p12

‘News n’ notes’ By Walt Andrus.’ ‘French Report.’

‘It was announced that Dr Hynek, Dr Vallee and Dr Niemtzow had recently flown to France to evaluate the work of GEPAN and to make recommendations upon future funding for UFO investigations and research by the French Government. They also met privately with Claude Poher former chief of GEPAN (see separate article in this issue concerning the visit as related by Richard Niemtzow on his return.)

MUFON Journal No. 208. Aug 1985. p13

‘Outside advice.’

‘In order to evaluate further funding for GEPAN, the Prime Minister of France sought the advice of sources independent of political and scientific personnel in France who might be prejudiced. Dr J Allen Hynek and Richard C Niemtzow were invited to met with government officials and to make recommendations for the consideration of GEPAN. Dr Jacques Vallee accompanied Dr Hynek and Niemtzow as an unofficial observer to the meetings and conferences due to his interest and knowledge.

The triumvirate arrived in Paris on June 23rd and had lunch with Claude Poher. Mr Poher is still very interested in UFOs. In spite of numerous rumours circulating a few years ago he is “alive and well.” Poher advised that he will continue to be watching the progress of GEPAN from the sidelines as it faces political attacks.

On Monday, June 24th, a conference was held at the French National Space Centre in Paris (Centre National D/Etudes Spatiales) attended by 20 to 30 space center officials and university professors. Both Dr Hynek and Niemtzow presented papers to this prestigious conclave. Dr Niemtzow’s paper was titled “Physiological and radiation effects from intense luminous un identified flying objects.’ And Dr Hynek’s was ‘An approach to the study of unidentified aerospace phenomenon.’ Hynek discussed his computerised UFO catalog and firmly advised that he supported the activity and efforts of GEPAN and recommended that it not be closed down.

Hynek and Niemtzow offered the co-operation of UFO organisations in the U.S.A., to GEPAN and encouraged international collaboration on exceptional UFO cases in either country.

If a significant case occurred in France, Dr Hynek and Niemtzow would be invited to participate and likewise GEPAN personnel would come to the United States. Unofficially Jacques Vallee was present as an observer to offer his support to GEPAN and recommend its continuance.

Dr Niemtzow, who speaks French fluently, having attended medical school in France, had two private conversations with top officials of the French space program. Mr Lions, Director of the National Space Centre, felt that GEPAN should continue in spite of political and scientific problems. Mr Gruau, Inspector General of the space centre and secretary to the GEPAN scientific council also supported the research work of GEPAN.

Space center

The National space center headquarters and offices of GEPAN in Toulouse was the site for the meetings on June 25th. Mr P Bescono, Under Director of the space center at Toulouse, welcomed the U.S.  consultants to the seminar/symposium-style all day meeting.

Dr Jacques Vallee presented a paper titled ‘Applications of methods of artificial intelligence for the screening of witness reports.’ This is a method of determining by telephone, using computer displayed questions, whether a case should be investigated further.

All three consultants recommended that GEPAN should continue in the future due to the wide collection of material that would otherwise be wasted.

They also met Dr Alain Esterle former chief of GEPAN who is now involved in evaluation of space programs. Dr Esterle obtained his Ph.D. from the University of Washington and while chief of GEPAN, he met with MUFON officers in Houston, Texas.

File access

On Wednesday June 26th, Hynek and Niemtzow had the pleasure of personal access to the GEPAN UFO file and computerised file. They found no evidence of humanoids or UFO crashes or any type of aggressive sightings such as radar or aircraft. All cases were very well investigated. They expressed their desire to continue working with GEPAN and Jean-Jacques Velasco the chief.

In the Paris meeting on June 24, a representative of the prime Minister was in the audience to observe and report back to his superior.

No press

For the record, Richard Niemtzow, M.D. was invited as a private citizen and consultant to the GEPAN meetings by the French government. In reality, Dr Niemtzow is a major in the U.S.A.F. Medical Corp stationed at Andrews AFB, Maryland. He has a Ph.D. in Biological Sciences Richard has been a MUFON consultant in Radiation since 1977, and is presently the state section director for Prince George’s county in Maryland.

The U.S.A.F approved of Dr Niemtzow’s visit to France, but he was forbidden to participate in any press conference due to the sensitive nature of his position. We are indebted to Dr Niemtzow for providing this information to the MUFON JOURNAL by telephone.

The Mutual UFO Network has been cooperating with GEPAN since its inception and will continue to do so. In our library, we have all their technical reports from No 3 dated April 1981 through No 18 dated March 15, 1983, and Note D’Information numbers 2,3 and 4.

MUFON Journal. No. 211. Nov 1985. p8

‘Massachusetts Forum’ by Walter N Webb.’

‘French Connection.’

‘As guests of the French National Space Center and GEPAN, the official UFO agency, Drs Hynek, Niemtzow and Vallee not only attended a two-day UFO conference in Paris and Toulouse but also presented papers that were well received (see August 1985 issue) …Niemtzow’s on UFO Related Medical Injuries…

MUFON Journal No 212. Dec 1985. p18

Article. Ware, D M ‘Security Policy.’

‘Dr Niemtzow’s medical data bank seems to be a superb effort that could benefit us all. It could shed light on alien actions and on the dangers of proximity to some UFOs.’

Vallee diary entry dated 30 March 1986

‘Richard Niemtzow came over for dinner on Thursday. We spent the evening in conversation, starting with the whole array of medical effects of UFOs such as the Dr. X skin coloration (I had brought back a series of new photographs from France) and ending with speculation about the structure of the problem as a whole.

“Aren’t we faced with a phenomenon that demands that we leave behind our classical methods? Doesn’t it mock out attempts to measure it?” he asked.

“Of course,” I said, “but that’s only more reason to drive all the measurements to their fullest extent, so we have calibration…”

…Richard had noticed the same thing as I did, about the phenomenon acting as a concentrator for coincidences…’

MUFON Journal No. 215. Mar 1986. p17

‘The UFO Phenomenon-A Research update.’

Announces that, on 19 April 1986 in Los Angeles, the LA section of the American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) will hold a session with speakers including Jean-Jacques Velasco; Richard Haines; Jacques Vallee and Richard Niemtzow.

MUFON Journal No 225. Jan 1987. p18

Article. Neal, Richard M. ‘Medical Injury Protocol.’

In an article reviewing the subject of medical injuries reported by UFO witnesses, the author explores reported physiological effects, and tests and documentation which would be useful to conduct. In the text of the article is the following:

‘UFO-MD, which was visualized by Dr Richard Niemtzow, produced only two cases from Oct 1, 1981 to Oct 1 1983. His objective was to study at least 12 cases of medical injuries associated with alleged UFO close encounters. It is clear that some type of national screening network is sorely needed for referral of cases.

As physicians, we are extremely frustrated because so many potentially good cases are lost due to lack of a referral system. Referral or sharing of information at this time would be appreciated.’

MUFON Journal No 233.Sep 1987. p23

‘Director’s Message,’ ‘The International Society of Air Safety Investigators (San Francisco Chapter) is conducting a “Symposium on the Investigation of UFOs and other Visual Anomalies” on September 12, 1987…speakers scheduled include…Richard Niemtzow, MD….’

Vallee diary entry dated 6 December 1987

‘Strange requests continue around Richard Niemtzow. He received a call from a French Lieutenant Colonel trained in pharmacology, a Dr Canonne, who said he was from the French Health Ministry. He was in the U.S. on his way to Russia, had a meeting planned at DIA. Richard was amused to be contacted ostensibly about UFOs. It was like the old French joke, the recipe for lark pate: “one lark,
one horse, one lark, one horse…” The man spoke a little about UFOs, a lot about microwaves…This reminded me of my visit to Poher. He was working on muscle paralysis using electromagnetism. He was talking to the military about this idea, since the process could lead to a non-lethal weapon. Poher is close to Niemtzow who is an expert on membranes’ electrical potential and ion transport on muscle cells.

“We like the way you’ve addressed the phenomenon,” Canonne told Richard “We’d like to learn more about the physical effects of microwaves on human tissue.”

“What are you really proposing?” asked Niemtzow.

“We’re going to send people from France, we’ve already written to DOD. Paul Tyler, a retired medical expert was mentioned.

“This was all very strange,” Niemtzow told me. “I assured this Dr Canonne that I could only help if the request was official. He suggested I serve as liaison to this French group. I’m very suspicious. 

The man even asked me if I’d be interested in returning to France, and gave me two bottles of wine before he left.”

“He didn’t know Velasco. He said his group wasn’t really interested in the phenomena but all the questions came back to it, which was really strange. He also said his project was classified. He gave an address on the Rue St. Charles, as Pharmacien en Chef, bureau des affaires scientifiques et techniques, Secretariat General de la Defense Nationale.” A scientist named Bernard Veyret [9], a French expert in microwaves was also mentioned. Thus the rejection of UFOs by French “rationalists” continues to serve as a cover for a very serious series of military Intelligence projects, run from Paris, probing into every aspect of the field.

Vallee diary entry dated 15 February 1989

“Last night I was kept awake by some remarks of Richard Niemtzow, who had called me from Texas earlier in the day. He was thinking of leaving the Air Force, where he was tired of doing radiation oncology in an environment of insufficient budgets. When the conversation turned to the possibility that the U.S. was hiding Aliens in its freezers I was surprised to find him ready to believe the undocumented anatomical descriptions circulated by Stringfield.

Richard assures me he was once within one phone call of a doctor who had done an autopsy on an alien. Of course “being within one phone call” means nothing as Kit had told me the doctor in question had not done an autopsy but was only asked to review the alleged results, quite a different thing.  But Dr Neal, who knows the guy told Richard that he started shaking visibly when the subject was brought up and that he asked to be left alone. That still doesn’t prove anything.’

Vallee diary entry dated 5 June 1989

‘I had a long friendly talk with Richard Niemtzow, about to be promoted to Lieutenant Colonel in the Air Force. He continues to be puzzled by the advances made to him by the French: Jean-Jacques Velasco makes it a point of paying him a visit later this month after the Boulder conference of the Society for Scientific Exploration.

“Why is he coming, if Gepan is getting disbanded?” asked Richard. And what about the team of microwave experts who visited him a few months ago, bringing with them a man from French Intelligence who is now stationed at the embassy in Switzerland?

“Why me?” Richard wonders. “I’m not a microwave expert. They have more qualified people over there. Could it be that they’re coming because of my UFO interests?”

Vallee diary entry dated 13 June 1989

‘Last night we had dinner with Jean-Jacques Velasco…He confirmed that some of the French teams interested in microwave weapons wanted to talk to Niemtzow, notably the shadowy Gilbert Payan who works for ETCA (Etablissement Technique Central de l’Armement.)’

   ‘Gilbert Payan, a graduate (1948) of Ecole Polytechnique and a specialist in power lasers, pursued parallel careers in industry and on the fringes of French secret military services. After post-graduate studies in Germany (1951-52) and at Cornell University (1952-53) Payan worked as a civil engineer, joining ENA (now Technip) in 1959, developing a petrochemical plant in Shiraz (Iran). From 1964-1971 he worked at Creusot-Loire as project leader on the Epsodie nuclear plant, becoming head of R&D in the mechanical department. In 1976 he was president of the Mechanics division of the DGRST (a military research center). From 1978 to 1981 he served as Chief Operating Officer, then CEO of Instruments SA, a company developing military optics. He became president of a franco-soviet group for scientific instrumentation in industry. In 1982 Payan was director of the Mechanics-robotics-optics department at the Ministry of research and technology, a position he left in 1985 to become advisor on power laser developments under the Eureka program. He became CEO of Jobin & Yvon about 1986. After 1990 he continued to work as a private consultant. [10]

Vallee diary entry dated 18 June 1989

‘I just spoke again to Richard Niemtzow: I told him that Dr. Richard Neal was trying to reach him. We ended up talking about France.

“Whenever Velasco comes here to talk about UFOs, all kinds of other stuff happens,” he said excitedly. “I’ve just had another call from Dr Bernard Veyret, who is doing research on electromagnetism at the University of Bordeaux. He’s the one who is trying to validate the Priore machine and the use of microwaves in cancer treatment.”

“Jean-Jacques did tell me about that.”

“Well, this Veyret is open minded about UFOs, but I don’t think that’s his real interest. He mentioned it might be possible for me to work half time at Sepra in Toulouse and half time in Bordeaux. Does that sound reasonable?”

“Yes, that’s interesting. Things are changing in France; you know: they are much more pragmatic today that just a few years ago.”

“Veyret tells me I should meet with Gilbert Payan, have you heard that name before?”

“Jean-Jacques did mention him: behind-the-scenes guy, especially interested in microwaves.”
I didn’t tell him that Jean-Jacques had told me, in the plane going to Boulder, that Payan was working closely with the military at ETCA, like our friend Francois Louange and that he was the one who had ordered the Petit experiments redone, sans Petit of course.

Payan aime le secret,” were Velasco’s exact words.

In the last few days I have been able to close many of the loops left open by our last trip to France and our discussion with Guerin.

“Payan is a consultant with the Defense Nationale,” Niemtzow went on. “Apparently he’s highly respected. They say he can get me a position in France. Jacqueline would also have a job.”
The fact remains that Richard is subtly being recruited to work in France on secret microwave projects, and I cannot shake the impression that Poher is aware of all that…According to Richard, Payan is in contact with a Monsieur Cannon, on Cannone, supposedly with French intelligence at the Embassy in Switzerland who travelled to the US on a mission hurriedly arranged by the Quai d’Orsay last year.’

Vallee diary entry dated 30 July 1989

‘Conversation with Richard Niemtzow: he left a message on my machine this week-end, stating he had just flown back from France where he had met with Jean-Jacques Velasco and “people within the hierarchy” representing the French government’s interest in the UFO question. When I called him back he first told me he had just been promoted to Lieutenant-Colonel in the Air Force and was still trying to decide whether or not to take a job in France. He did interview for a position where he would head up oncology clinical trials but he was disappointed at the offer, so the move does not make sense.

He went on to Paris where he met Gilbert Payan and Jean-Jacques Velasco. Payan invited them to lunch at his apartment so there were no witnesses to their discussions of UFOs and physiological effects of microwaves. Although Payan presented himself as a high-ranking official of the Ministry of research, Richard suspected he was a specialist in scientific intelligence using the research ministry as a cover. He kept Richard and Jacqueline most of the afternoon asking many questions but providing few answers himself. He was evasive when asked about the future of the French program at Cnes.

During the lunch, which was formal, with Payan keeping his jacket and tie, in spite of the sweltering heat (I joked that he could not take them off because his tape recorder was inside his breast pocket, his tie hiding the wire.) Payan mentioned that France was making progress on ionic propulsion systems. He had also been associated with Poher’s project to camouflage automated UFO detection devices into atmospheric monitoring stations, and effort that went nowhere.

Payan asked Richard questions about microwaves; would they interfere with recording equipment? No, replied Richard with the impression Payan already had the answers. The apartment had an excellent UFO library; Payan knew my work and had read all of Niemtzow’s papers. He clearly occupies a position of clout in the administration, from which he plans to retire in a few months, but Richard had the impression he did not know much more than we did on UFOs, while he was very up-to-date about the aerospace industry, both French and American. Space travel seems to be his dominant interest, along with sophisticated weapons: his interest in UFOs is linked to the desire to manufacture a “ray” that could paralyse people at a distance like these objects do. Dr Cannone, of French intelligence, was again mentioned as his “collaborator. And Payan considered the idea of hiring Richard as a consultant on these issues.

Whenever they discussed UFOs it was the medical aspect that came back. Would certain types of radiation be useful in paralysing muscles? What was the effect of microwaves on tissue? At what frequencies? These were the topics he wanted to discuss. They correlated closely with those asked by Dr Bernard Veyret of Bordeaux University Medical School, himself one expert on radiation impact on human tissue who recently visited Richard in Texas.

…Velasco had told Niemtzow about a highly confidential French government paper on microwave activity that mentioned work at Brooks Air Force Base, among other things… When Richard asked Velasco if he ever saw Poher he was told that they had not met for a long time…’

Vallee diary entry dated 31 July 1989

‘Richard Niemtzow is puzzled: Velasco has left a message on his machine asking him again to send his biography urgently “as Cnes was considering making him an offer of employment.’
Payan has to be behind this move. Richard wonders if he should take the job in France to see what is going on, and if he should tell Kit about all this.’

Vallee diary entry dated 23 August 1989

‘Richard Niemtzow…picked me up at the airport. We had the whole evening to discuss topics we hadn’t been able to voice over the phone, notably the puzzling developments in France and our mutual relationship to Kit. Richard showed me the latest letter from Gilbert Payan (from Boulogne) inviting him to France. It suggested that he contact was woman named Annie Wolff who seems to be his assistant.

As he told me before, it hinted that they could help him secure a job at Hoffman-La Roche while he would be supplementing his income working for “them” as a consultant. But who is “them?”
Another document Richard gave me answered the question: it was an excellent summary of biological effects of weak microwaves written by thee scientists form Bordeaux University on behalf of the SGDN, the General Secretariat for National Defense.

“Clearly the French are moving towards the development of what they call MOPAP weapons, Anti-Personal Pulsed Microwaves,” he said.

“Do you think I should go there and join their project? See where it leads? My wife is French; we could easily move back. Payan has hinted I could work with Velasco in Toulouse. I could become active in their UFO work…I have good contacts with amateur groups in France… If I go there should I tell Kit what is going on? Perhaps he would want me to gather information for him…”

Payan is no dummy. He must know quite well that Niemtzow has to report on such contacts…

(Niemtzow.) “Those people are clumsy: they screw up the simplest jobs. When the French came her, I arranged their trip and then contacted AFOSI, our own Air Force Intelligence, to brief them on the visit. They didn’t want me to come to their office because that was too obvious…”

Vallee diary entry dated 10 December 1989

‘A brief conversation with Richard Niemtzow on Friday had brought another surprise. He prefaced it by saying that the Air Force has made plans to send him overseas instead of moving him to Washington where his family lives. Her is now a fully-fledged flight surgeon. Accordingly, he has approached a colonel who heads up another Department on the base to see if he could transfer to his unit. After the customary interview the man asked him about any other interests he might have. He mentioned UFOs.

“I’ve had some acquaintance with the subject myself,” said the colonel. “So have a number of our pilots, but of course it’s difficult to discuss it in the open.” After a brief silence he told Niemtzow: “We really ought to have lunch and pursue this UFO thing together…He went on, much to Richard’s amazement “Have you met Dr Robert Bright, the forensic pathologist here? Why don’t you ask him some day about some of the autopsies he’s done?”’

MUFON Journal. No 277. May 1991. p24

‘Director’s Message.’ ‘…Richard D (sic) Niemtzow, M.D. (Clovis, New Mexico) for Curry, Quay, De Baca and Roosvelt Counties. Dr Niemtzow is also a consultant in Radiation and a member since 1977.

MUFON Journal. No 283. Nov 1991. p13

Article. Neal, R M. ‘Paralysis by microwaves.’

The author discusses the possible mechanisms which might lead to paralysis in association with UFO close encounters.

1.       Very much a new look at Neimotzow’s work since 1975.

How many cases involving injury did Dr Niemtzow personally investigate and document?

There are:

1. The 1979 two cases at Tyler, Texas. However, while there are layman’s descriptions of the injuries, there are no medical, physician style reports provided in the article. (MUFON J No 139, Sep 1979 pp3-4.) Indeed, the authors write: ‘Without the full and continued cooperation of both Ron and Scott it is impossible to draw firm conclusions from the information given to date…Scott…desires no publicity and will no longer cooperate in the investigation.’

2. Then there is the 1908 Cash-Landrum incident. Dr Niemtzow in an article in the MUFON J No 179 Jan 1983 pp14-16 writes, on the Cash-Landrum case, ‘I will only speculate what occurred in the Cash-Landrum case because I never examined or had access to their medical records.’ This despite the fact that the lead investigator was John Schuessler, a fellow member of VISIT. However, John Scheussler in his 1998 book ‘The Cash-Landrum UFO Incident.’ (Geo Graphics Printing Co., La Porte, Texas) on page 107 explanation this by stating ‘Then on March 12, 1981, I received an offer of help from a highly qualified radiation medicine professional. He was Dr Peter Rank, Chief of the Deaprtment of Radiology at Methodist Hospital in Madison, Wisconsin…Under Dr Rank’s guidance we were able to set up the protocol for obtaining medical records as well as discussing the results of the treatments.’

Is there any other information?

a. In the MUFON J no 225 Jan 1987 p 15 article Dr Neal wrote: ‘UFO-MD, which was visualized by Dr Richard Niemtzow, produced only two cases from Oct 1, 1981 to Oct 1 1983.’

b. Jacques Vallee’s diary entry dated 24 June 1985 states: ‘…Fortunately Richard Niemtzow saved the day with an impeccable presentation on medical effects. He mentioned Cash-Landrum, Bentwaters and six cases in Texas, including the diamond-shaped skin discolouration noted in Tyler on 24 January 1979.’

c. ‘The author has had the occasion to examine several patients with alleged medical injuries from unidentified flying objects. In all of the cases, the event occurred several months before the "patient" seeked medical help. One case still had a chest lesion that was slowly fading, but refused a biopsy. Two similar chest lesions came to my attention in both the USA and France. Several laboratory tests were made with GEPAN on an individual alleged to be abducted. The laboratory results were normal and the case proved to be a hoax. In no instances has the author reviewed a series of cases where clinical laboratory correlations have been made. (The article by Richard C. Niemtzow, entitled Physiological and radiation effects from intense luminous unidentified objects, first appeared in URIP, Vol.11, No2/3 (1984).)

The same article informed that: ‘Two cases, both of which had no apparent value, were the only yield in two years. Because of the paucity of information, UFOMD was suspended.’


[1] Curriculum Vitae (current as at 3 July 2014)

[2] Bourdais, G. “From GEPAN to SEPRA: Official UFO Studies in France.” International UFO Reporter. Winter 2000-2001, pp10-13.


[4] Bourdais, G. “From GEPAN to SEPRA: Official UFO Studies in France.” International UFO Reporter. Winter 2000-2001 pp10-13.


[6] MUFON Journal No. 208. Aug 1985. p13


[8] Vallee, J. 2016. ‘Forbidden Science-Volume Three.’ Documatica Research, LLC.


[10] Vallee, J. 2016. ‘Forbidden Science – Volume Three.’ Documatica Research, LLC.